Defensive Practices in Contemporary Nursing: Implications, Challenges, and Adaptive Responses Publisher



Golitaleb M ; Safdari A
Source: International Journal of Africa Nursing Sciences Published:2026

Abstract

Defensive practices are increasingly common in healthcare, often motivated by legal concerns rather than clinical needs. While this phenomenon has been extensively studied in medicine, its effects on nursing remain insufficiently explored. Nurses, who have close and sustained contact with patients, are particularly vulnerable to medico-legal pressures. In response, they may engage in defensive behaviors such as excessive documentation, avoiding high-risk procedures, or performing unnecessary interventions. While these actions may provide legal protection, they can compromise the quality of care, strain patient relationships, reduce professional satisfaction, and distract from genuine patient needs. It is important to recognize that defensive practices arise not from individual shortcomings but from systemic issues and institutional cultures that fail to adequately support healthcare workers. Addressing this situation requires more than legal training; it necessitates the integration of legal literacy within ethical, patient-centered frameworks. This means encouraging transparent communication and fostering environments that prioritize learning over punishment. To ensure ethical and effective nursing care, it is essential to equip nurses with the skills needed to navigate legal complexities without compromising their practice. Additional empirical research is necessary to fully understand the impact of defensive nursing and to guide meaningful systemic reform. © 2025 The Authors.